Get free shipping on your order, with any water filter subscription. Find my filter

Open Hamburger Menu
Sears Parts Direct
Tips to find your model number
Maytag MBL2258XES1 refrigerator

Maytag MBL2258XES1 refrigerator Parts

Here are the diagrams and repair parts for Maytag MBL2258XES1 refrigerator, as well as links to manuals and error code tables, if available.

By Schematic
By Part
SELECT DIAGRAM
?

This is the number corresponding to the part on the diagram / schematic

Browse Parts for MBL2258XES1 Refrigerators

  • Refrigerator Fill Cup for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part W10122561

    Icemaker parts diagram

    Refrigerator Fill Cup

    Part #628515

    Replaced by #W10122561

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces 628515. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    This item is not returnable
    In Stock
    $19.84
    9% OFF Phone Price : $21.84Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Refrigerator Drain Funnel for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part W10815413

    Freezer liner parts diagram

    Refrigerator Funnel

    Part #D7753903

    Replaced by #W10815413

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces D7753903. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    In Stock
    $75.95
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Refrigerator Door Handle (stainless) for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part W10252288A

    Refrigerator Handle

    Part #W10252288N

    Replaced by #W10252288A

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces W10252288N. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    In Stock
    $60.16
    9% OFF Phone Price : $66.16Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Refrigerator Toe Grille for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part WPW10534162

    Cabinet parts diagram

    Refrigerator Grille

    Part #W10236196

    Replaced by #WPW10534162

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces W10236196. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    In Stock
    $74.07
    7% OFF Phone Price : $80.07Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Ikea Refrigerator Roller Wheel Axle Pin for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part 67006434

    Unit parts diagram

    Axle- Roll

    Part #12477202

    Replaced by #67006434

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces 12477202. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    In Stock
    $7.67
    12% OFF Phone Price : $8.67Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Appliance Spray Paint (biscuit) for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part 4392901

    Optional parts diagram

    Bisq Paint

    Part #4392901

    Replaced by #4392901

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces 4392901. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    This item is not returnable
    In Stock
    $32.75
    15% OFF Phone Price : $38.75Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Inglis Refrigerator Screw for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part 67006564

    Cabinet parts diagram

    Screw- Sm

    Part #12991302

    Replaced by #67006564

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces 12991302. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    This item is not returnable
    In Stock
    $4.91
    17% OFF Phone Price : $5.91Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Shaft-rack 33 for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part W11715937

    Freezer liner parts diagram

    Refrigerator Freezer Drawer Shaft

    Part #12812902WD

    Replaced by #W11715937

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces 12812902WD. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    In Stock
    $106.28
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Refrigerator Roller for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part WP67005149

    Unit parts diagram

    Refrigerator Roller

    Part #12477102

    Replaced by #WP67005149

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces 12477102. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    This item is not returnable
    In Stock
    $22.33
    21% OFF Phone Price : $28.33Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item
  • Refrigerator Air Damper Cover for Maytag MBL2258XES1 - Part WP12806701

    Refrigerator liner parts diagram

    Refrigerator Damper Cover

    Part #12806701

    Replaced by #WP12806701

    Info Icon
    Manufacturer substitution
    This part replaces 12806701. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
    In Stock
    $36.39
    29% OFF Was : $51.02Info Icon
    Minus Item
    Qty
    Plus Item

Maytag Refrigerator MBL2258XES1 FAQs

Most bottom-freezer refrigerators typically last about 12 to 15 years with normal use and routine maintenance. For your Maytag MBL2258XES1 bottom-mount refrigerator, keeping airflow clear, doors sealing well, and the cooling system clean helps you reach that expected lifespan; see the MBL2258XES1 owner's manual for care and safety guidance.

Typical lifespan and what affects it

A refrigerator’s life depends less on the freezer location and more on how hard the sealed system and fans have to work.

  • Maintenance: dirty condenser area and blocked vents shorten life
  • Door seal condition: air leaks force longer run times
  • Room conditions: hot garages and tight cabinets increase compressor load
  • Usage: frequent door openings and overpacking reduce efficiency
  • Water/ice system health: leaks and clogs can cause secondary damage
Quick maintenance checklist (best ROI)
  • Keep interior air vents clear in both compartments
  • Make sure doors close fully and sit level
  • Clean dust from the condenser area regularly
  • Replace worn door gaskets if you feel cold air leaking
  • Address water leaks quickly (especially around the inlet valve and drain)
Common “end-of-life” symptoms vs fixable issues
Symptom Often fixable? Common area to check
Warm fridge, freezer OK Yes Airflow/damper, evaporator fan
Loud buzzing/clicking at start Sometimes Start components, compressor circuit
Frost buildup on back wall Yes Defrost system
Water under fridge Yes Drain system, water line/valve
Why it matters

Knowing the typical 12 to 15 year lifespan helps you decide whether to invest in repairs (like a fan motor or control) or plan for replacement if major sealed-system work is needed.

Last updated: January 2026

A bottom-mount refrigerator like the Maytag MBL2258XES1 is usually “better” if you want fresh-food items at eye level and a wider refrigerator section; a top-mount is usually “better” if you want a simpler layout and often a lower purchase price. The best choice depends on how you use your refrigerator daily.

Quick comparison (what most homeowners notice)
Feature Top-mount (freezer on top) Bottom-mount (freezer on bottom)
Fresh-food access More bending Less bending; fridge at eye level
Freezer access Easy reach More bending; drawer style on many models
Organization Basic shelves and bins Often better fridge organization; freezer baskets
Energy use Often slightly lower Often slightly higher (varies by model)
Cost Often lower Often higher
How to choose for your kitchen and habits
  • Choose bottom-mount if you use the refrigerator section far more than the freezer.
  • Choose top-mount if you want a straightforward design with fewer moving drawer parts.
  • If you store lots of frozen foods, compare freezer layout (shelves vs baskets) and how often you dig to the bottom.
  • If you have limited space, confirm door swing and clearance needs before deciding.
  • If you have an ice maker or water line, plan for extra space behind the unit for connections.
Why it matters (comfort, space, and installation)

Bottom-mount designs reduce bending for everyday items like milk, produce, and leftovers, which is why many people prefer them long-term. Installation details also matter: for proper ventilation and door swing clearance, follow the spacing guidance in the MBL2258XES1 owner's manual.

Helpful tip for long-term performance

No matter which style you choose, good airflow and correct placement help the compressor and condenser run efficiently. Keep the refrigerator away from heat sources and maintain the recommended clearances.

Last updated: January 2026

Yes. On the Maytag MBL2258XES1, you can lower the cabinet slightly by adjusting the front rollers or leveling screws behind the base grille; turning the adjustment to the left (or counterclockwise, depending on style) lowers that side.

How to lower the refrigerator (leveling/roller adjustment)

Follow the steps in the MBL2258XES1 owner's manual for your exact base style.

  • Unplug the refrigerator or switch off power for safety.
  • Remove the base grille (kick plate) by gripping it firmly and pulling it toward you.
  • If your model has roller adjustment screws: use a 3/8-inch hex driver.
  • If your model has leveling screws: use a 1/4-inch hex driver.
  • Turn the adjustment to lower the refrigerator:
    • Roller style: turn the roller adjustment screw to the left.
    • Leveling-screw style: turn the leveling screw counterclockwise.
  • Adjust both sides the same amount so the cabinet stays level side-to-side.
Quick reference: which way to turn?
Adjustment type Tool To lower height
Front roller adjustment screw 3/8-inch hex driver Turn left
Leveling screw 1/4-inch hex driver Turn counterclockwise
Door closing check (important)

After lowering, we recommend checking door swing and self-closing:

  • Open and release the refrigerator door; it should close smoothly.
  • If the door does not close easily, tilt the refrigerator slightly more to the rear by turning both adjustments to the right (or clockwise) a little at a time.
  • Reinstall the base grille when finished.
Why it matters

Lowering the front too much can reduce the slight rearward tilt that helps the doors seal. A poor seal can cause warm temperatures, frost, or longer compressor run times.

Last updated: January 2026

The most common Maytag refrigerator problems are cooling complaints (not cold enough or running too much) and ice maker or water dispensing issues. On the Maytag MBL2258XES1, these symptoms are often tied to airflow, temperature control settings, or water supply components rather than a single “one part” failure.

Most common symptoms and what they usually point to
  • Refrigerator not cold enough: dirty condenser coils, blocked vents, or a weak evaporator fan
  • Runs constantly: warm room, frequent door openings, dirty coils, or door gasket leaks
  • Ice maker not making ice: restricted water flow, frozen fill tube, or a failing ice maker
  • Water dispenser slow or no water: clogged filter, air in the line, or a weak inlet valve
  • Frost buildup or warm freezer: defrost system issue (heater, control, airflow)
Quick checks we recommend first (fast, no parts)
  1. Confirm the controls are turned on and set correctly; the manual notes that setting the controls to the coldest setting will not cool faster.
  2. If the refrigerator was recently installed or restarted, allow 24 hours to cool completely.
  3. Make sure the doors close fully and vents are not blocked by food packages.
  4. If you have ice or water issues, verify the household water supply valve is fully open.
Common parts involved when symptoms persist
Symptom Common suspect part Example part for MBL2258XES1
No ice or intermittent ice Ice maker Refrigerator ice maker D7824706Q
No water to ice maker/dispenser Water inlet valve Refrigerator water inlet valve assembly WP2315576
Warm fridge, noisy, poor airflow Evaporator fan motor Refrigerator evaporator motor W11024089
Frost buildup, warm temps Defrost heater Refrigerator defrost heater WP12729128
Why it matters

Cooling and ice maker problems often share the same root causes: restricted airflow, incorrect temperature control use, or restricted water flow. Fixing the basic cause first helps avoid replacing good parts and restores stable temperatures faster.

For model-specific operating and troubleshooting steps, follow the MBL2258XES1 owner's manual.

Last updated: January 2026

Most common symptoms to help you fix your refrigerators

Choose a symptom to see related refrigerator repairs.

Main causes: leaky door gasket, defrost system failure, evaporator fan not running, dirty condenser coils, condenser fan…

Main causes: control board or cold control failure, broken compressor start relay, compressor motor failure, defrost tim…

Main causes: blocked vents, defrost system problems, evaporator fan failure, dirty condenser coils, bad sensors, condens…

Main causes: blocked air vents, compressor problems, condenser or evaporator fan not working, control system failure, se…

Main causes: water valve leaking, frozen or broken defrost drain tube, overflowing drain pan, cracked water system tubin…

Main causes: damaged door seal, faulty defrost sensor or bi-metal thermostat, broken defrost heater, bad defrost timer o…

Things to do: clean condenser coils, replace the water filter, clean the interior, adjust doors to prevent air leaks, cl…

Main causes: jammed ice cubes, broken ice maker assembly, dirty water filter, kinked water line, bad water valve, freeze…

Most common repair guides to help fix your refrigerators

These step-by-step repair guides will help you safely fix what’s broken on your refrigerator.

How to replace a refrigerator temperature control board

How to replace a refrigerator temperature control board

If the temperature in your refrigerator doesn't match the temperature you set, the problem could be the temperature cont…

Repair time and Difficulty

 30 minutes or less
How to replace a refrigerator water valve

How to replace a refrigerator water valve

Replace the water valve that feeds water to the ice maker and water dispenser if it no longer controls the flow of water…

Repair time and Difficulty

 15 minutes or less
How to clean refrigerator condenser coils

How to clean refrigerator condenser coils

Help your refrigerator run more efficiently by cleaning the condenser coils. It's easy and takes just a few minutes.…

Repair time and Difficulty

 15 minutes or less

Effective articles & videos to help repair your refrigerators

Use the advice and tips in these articles and videos to get the most out of your refrigerator.

How to Replace the Water Filter in a Universal/Multiflex Refrigerator

How to Replace the Water Filter in a Universal/Multiflex Refrigerator

Learn how easy replacing the water filter in a Universal/Multiflex refrigerator is.…

How to Replace the Water Filter in a KitchenAid Refrigerator

How to Replace the Water Filter in a KitchenAid Refrigerator

Discover how easy it is to replace the water filter in your KitchenAid refrigerator.…

Troubleshooting a refrigerator not cooling video

Troubleshooting a refrigerator not cooling video

Learn what to check if the inside of your fridge is wayyyy too warm.…

Parts & More

Bottom-Mount Refrigerator
Dehumidifier
Electric Range
Exercise Cycle
Front-Engine Lawn Tractor
Gas Line Trimmer
Gas Pressure Washer
Gas Snowblower
Parts
Range
Refrigerator
Side-By-Side Refrigerator
Treadmill
Washer