What are the disadvantages of a bottom freezer refrigerator?
Bottom-freezer refrigerators like the Maytag MFI2570FEZ09 make fresh-food access easier at eye level, but the tradeoffs are a lower freezer drawer that requires bending, a deeper space that can be harder to organize, and more parts around the drawer, rails, and drain/defrost system that can create occasional maintenance issues.
Common disadvantages (what you will notice day to day)
- You bend more to reach frozen foods, especially items stored at the bottom of the drawer.
- Deep freezer drawers can hide smaller packages unless you use bins or a strict “front-to-back” system.
- Heavy items (bulk meat, frozen drinks) are lifted up from a low position, which is harder on backs and knees.
- Freezer access can feel less convenient if you open the freezer frequently throughout the day.
- Drawer alignment matters; if the unit is not level, the freezer drawer can feel stiff or not seal as well.
Maintenance and repair considerations
Bottom-mount designs commonly have more “moving interface” parts at the freezer, which can mean more wear points over time.
| Area | What can happen | Typical symptom |
|---|---|---|
| Freezer drawer/rails | Misalignment or drag | Drawer feels hard to open/close |
| Door gaskets | Poor seal from gaps or warping | Frost, sweating, temperature swings |
| Drain/defrost path | Ice or debris buildup | Water puddles, ice under drawer |
For model-specific leveling and door alignment guidance, use the owner's manual.
Why it matters
If your household uses the refrigerator section far more than the freezer, bottom-mount is usually a comfort win. If you use the freezer constantly or store lots of small frozen items, the drawer depth and bending can be the biggest downside.
Practical ways to reduce the downsides
- Keep “daily-use” frozen foods in the upper basket or top layer.
- Group small items in bins so they do not disappear under larger packages.
- Level the refrigerator so the drawer tracks smoothly and seals consistently.
- Keep gaskets clean so the doors close firmly and temperatures stay stable.
Last updated: February 2026
Is it better to have a freezer on top or bottom of the refrigerator?
For most households, a bottom-freezer design like the Maytag MFI2570FEZ09 is the better everyday layout because the fresh-food section (what you use most) sits at eye level, so you bend less and access items faster. A top-freezer can be a good choice when you want the simplest, most budget-focused design.
Quick comparison: top vs bottom freezer
| Feature | Bottom freezer (like MFI2570FEZ09) | Top freezer |
|---|---|---|
| Fresh-food access | Most convenient (eye level) | Less convenient (more bending) |
| Freezer access | More bending (drawer) | Most convenient (eye level) |
| Organization | Often better freezer organization (baskets/dividers) | Often simpler shelves |
| Typical cost/complexity | Usually higher | Usually lower |
When a bottom freezer is the better choice
- You use the refrigerator section more than the freezer
- You want less bending for produce, drinks, and leftovers
- You like a wide refrigerator compartment for trays and platters
- You prefer a freezer drawer that can hold bulky items
When a top freezer can be the better choice
- You use frozen foods daily and want them at eye level
- You want a simpler design with fewer features to maintain
- You are prioritizing upfront cost over convenience
Why it matters
The “best” freezer position is mostly about ergonomics and how your household uses food. Bottom-freezer refrigerators typically make daily tasks easier because the most-used items are in the fresh-food section, while top-freezer models can be a practical fit for heavy freezer use and simpler ownership.
For model-specific use and care tips (including temperature set points and operating features), follow the MFI2570FEZ09 owner's manual.
Last updated: February 2026
Why does my Maytag bottom freezer build up ice on the bottom?
Ice on the bottom of the freezer in your Maytag MFI2570FEZ09 almost always happens when the defrost drain clogs; defrost water cannot flow to the drain pan, so it refreezes on the freezer floor and builds into a sheet of ice. See the owner's manual for model-specific care and troubleshooting guidance.
Most common cause
A clogged defrost drain (often from food particles, ice, or debris) traps meltwater under the evaporator area. That water then runs forward and freezes at the bottom of the freezer.
What we recommend doing first
- Unplug the refrigerator (or turn off power at the breaker).
- Remove the freezer drawer/bins so you can see the ice buildup.
- Melt the ice on the freezer floor using a hair dryer on low or by placing towels and letting it thaw.
- Locate the drain opening (typically under the evaporator cover area) and clear visible debris.
- Flush the drain with hot water using a turkey baster or squeeze bottle until it flows freely.
- Confirm the drain tube at the back (near the drain pan) is not kinked or blocked.
Quick symptom guide
| What you notice | What it usually points to | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Solid ice sheet on freezer bottom | Defrost drain clogged | Drain hole and drain tube |
| Water pooling then freezing after defrost | Partial drain restriction | Hot-water flush, debris in drain |
| Frost plus warm temps | Airflow/defrost issue | Evaporator cover area, fan airflow |
Parts that can be involved (when clearing the drain is not enough)
If you clear the drain and the problem returns quickly, we typically look for airflow or temperature-sensing issues that can increase frost and overwhelm drainage.
- Evaporator airflow problems (ice buildup can worsen if airflow is restricted)
- Temperature sensing problems (can affect defrost timing)
- Door sealing issues letting humid air in
For temperature-sensing concerns, the refrigerator thermistor W10316760 is a common component used to monitor temperatures.
Why it matters
Ice buildup on the freezer floor can block the drawer from closing, reduce airflow, and lead to temperature swings that affect ice production and food quality.
Last updated: February 2026





