Get free shipping on your order, with any water filter subscription. Find my filter

Open Hamburger Menu
Sears Parts Direct
Tips to find your model number
Official Penfield Water heater parts

Penfield Water heater Parts — Browse All Models

Penfield water heaters are often installed and then forgotten until there's no hot water or the water gets cold halfway through a shower. If your Penfield water heater doesn't heat quickly enough, doesn't heat at all or your hot water smells like rotten eggs, find the replacement parts you need to fix the problem at Sears PartsDirect.

Frequently bought Penfield parts

Kenmore Water Heater Temperature And Pressure Relief Valve 100108279

Water Heater Temperature And Pressure Relief Valve

Part #9000071

Replaced by #100108279

Info Icon
Manufacturer substitution
This part replaces 9000071. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
In Stock
$77.83
7% OFF Phone Price : $83.83Info Icon
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Water Heater Drain Valve 100108269

Drain

Part #9000058

Replaced by #100108269

Info Icon
Manufacturer substitution
This part replaces 9000058. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
In Stock
$28.07
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Flue Baffle 9001207

Flue Baffle

In Stock
$116.14
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Knob 9001315

Knob

In Stock
$25.62
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Water Heater Thermostat, Lower 100108421

Thermostat

Part #9000054

Replaced by #100108421

Info Icon
Manufacturer substitution
This part replaces 9000054. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
In Stock
$59.50
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Thermostat 9000510

Thermostat

In Stock
$31.97
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item

Popular maintenance items for Water Heaters

Ao Smith Water Heater Thermistor 100263932

Ao Smith Water Heater Thermistor

In Stock
$61.39
9% OFF Phone Price : $67.39Info Icon
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Kenmore Water Heater Gas Control Valve 100262939

Kenmore Water Heater Gas Control Valve

In Stock
$284.09
27% OFF Was : $386.60Info Icon
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Water Heater Anode Rod 100110266

Water Heater Anode Rod

In Stock
$144.41
8% OFF Phone Price : $156.41Info Icon
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item

How to replace an electric heating element in your Penfield water heater

  • Switch the 2 house circuit breakers dedicated for the water heater to OFF. Wear work gloves to protect your hands.
  • Turn off the cold water supply to the water heater. Attach a garden hose to the drain valve located at the bottom of the unit and run the garden hose outside. Open a hot water faucet in the house or flip the relief valve open on the water heater. Open the drain valve and allow the tank to drain until empty.
  • Remove the heating element’s access cover mounting screw and pull off the cover. Fold the insulation back to expose the heating element. Lift up the tab located at the top of the plastic shield to release the shield from the thermostat and remove the shield. Loosen the screws securing the wires to the heating element and disconnect the wires. Unscrew the heating element from the tank using a heating element socket. Pull the heating element out of the tank.
  • Insert the new heating element in the tank and tighten firmly. Reconnect the wires to the new heating element and tighten the screws. Reinstall the plastic shield over the thermostat and heating element. Fold the insulation back over the thermostat and heating element. Reinstall the heating element cover and screw.
  • Close the drain valve and remove the garden hose. Flip the relief valve to the closed position. Turn the cold water supply on to the water heater and allow the tank to fill with water. Once you see water coming out of the hot water faucet, turn the hot water faucet off.
  • Flip the house circuit breakers to the on position.

How to replace the anode rod in your Penfield water heater

  • Shut off the house circuit breaker or circuit breakers for your water heater to completely disconnect electrical power. If you have a gas water heater shut off the gas supply.
  • Turn off the cold water supply to the water heater. Attach a garden hose to the drain valve located at the bottom of the unit and run the garden hose outside. Open a hot water faucet in the house or flip the relief valve open on the water heater. Open the drain valve and allow the tank to drain about 5 gallons of water and then close the drain valve and remove the garden hose.
  • Pry the plastic cap off from the top of the water heater covering the anode rod. Remove the foam insulation covering the anode rod. Unthread the anode rod and pull it up and out from the tank.
  • Wrap pipe thread-sealing tape around the threads of the new anode rod. Thread the new anode rod into the tank and tighten firmly. Reinsert the plastic cap.
  • Turn the cold water supply on to the water heater and allow the tank to fill with water. When water begins to flow from the open hot water faucet, turn the hot water faucet off.
  • Restore the electrical power supply (and gas supply for a gas water heater) to the water heater.

When you’re looking for hot water repair near me, trust the pros at Sears Home Services to fix your water heater fast.

Parts & More

Bottom-Mount Refrigerator
Canister Vacuum
Chest Freezer
Dishwasher
Dryer
Front-Engine Lawn Tractor
Gas Range
Gas Snowblower
Parts
Side-By-Side Refrigerator
Television
Wall Oven
Washer