Get free shipping on your order, with any water filter subscription. Find my filter

Open Hamburger Menu
Sears Parts Direct
Tips to find your model number
Official Toastmaster Toaster parts

Toastmaster Toaster Parts — Browse All Models

Toastmaster manufactures a wide variety of toasters so you can find the size and type of toaster that fits your needs. When your toaster isn't heating or it doesn't pop the toast up properly, find the repair parts your need to fix the problem at Sears PartsDirect.

Browse by Category
Toasters

Popular maintenance items for Toasters

Tray W11676547

Tray

Part #W10817300

Replaced by #W11676547

Info Icon
Manufacturer substitution
This part replaces W10817300. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
In Stock
$38.23
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Tray W10539052

Tray

In Stock
$138.48
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Bridge W10197739

Bridge

In Stock
$45.82
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Washer 4176830

Washer

In Stock
$28.02
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Housing WPW10539057

Housing

Part #W10539057

Replaced by #WPW10539057

Info Icon
Manufacturer substitution
This part replaces W10539057. Substitute parts can look different from the original.
In Stock
$489.25
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item
Rack W10567062

Rack

In Stock
$140.16
Minus Item
Qty
Plus Item

Common Toastmaster toaster repair parts

  • Heating element. If your Toastmaster toaster isn't toasting bread evenly, then a heating element may be bad. Check the heating elements and replace an element if it isn't heating properly.
  • Ejection trigger. Replace the ejection trigger is it's damaged and won't pop the toast up at the end of the toasting cycle.
  • Power cord. Replace the power cord if the cord is cut or damaged.

Parts & More

Bottom-Mount Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Dryer
Electric Range
Front-Engine Lawn Tractor
Gas Snowblower
Gas Walk-Behind Mower
Parts
Range
Rear-Engine Riding Mower
Refrigerator
Side-By-Side Refrigerator
Washer